Former India opener Sadagoppan Ramesh has taken aim at team management over what he sees as a glaring inconsistency in how India’s fitness protocols are being applied—specifically, the contrasting treatment given to Jasprit Bumrah and young quick Harshit Rana.
Bumrah, who was ruled out of the Sri Lanka Test series with a left knee injury, is reportedly being lined up to prove his fitness the hard way—through India. A red-ball fixture in New Zealand ahead of the senior team’s two-Test tour of the Kiwis. The logic from the think tank: no shortcuts back into the XI without runs on the board, or in this case, overs in the legs.
But it’s this very demand that has Ramesh crying foul. Why, he asks, is the same litmus test not being applied to Harshit Rana, who has also carried his own share of injury concerns? For Ramesh, the optics are hard to ignore—one bowler is made to earn his stripes on the domestic circuit before a recall, while another appears to get a pass.
The former Tamil Nadu batter didn’t mince words, questioning whether the selection committee is operating off a clear, uniform fitness framework — or making case-by-case calls that leave room for perceptions of favoritism. With India’s Test squad set to be finalized in the coming weeks, Ramesh’s comments add another layer of scrutiny to a management already under the pump over workload management of its premier pace attack.
Speaking on his YouTube channel, Ramesh didn’t hold back on what he sees as a selective application of fitness logic.
“It’s being reported that because Bumrah hasn’t played a red-ball game since November last year, he must play the India A games against New Zealand to be considered for selection. Fair enough—that’s a reasonable call, and honestly the right one to make,” Ramesh said. “But here’s the thing — with him, it’s a knee injury. And yet you picked Harshit Rana straight off knee surgery, straight into the squad. It’s pretty obvious that the rules bend for some people at some times, and not for others.”
Harshit Rana was sidelined from the 2026 T20 World Cup and missed the IPL season altogether after undergoing knee surgery. He was back in the India T20I squad for the tour of Ireland and England, with no match practice under his belt to speak of.
The gamble didn’t pay off. Midway through the England leg of the series, Harshit picked up a hamstring injury that ended his tour prematurely, raising fresh questions about whether he’d been rushed back too soon.
Ramesh went further, highlighting what he sees as a two-tier system where established stars are held to a far stricter standard than up-and-coming players.
“What I’m saying is simple—keep the parameters the same for everyone,” he said. “If anything, it’s the proven, established cricketers who end up under the most scrutiny. Look at Bumrah; even Shami was made to prove his fitness before coming back. But how Harshit Rana was picked straight after injury, with zero explanation—the BCCI has never addressed that.”
He didn’t stop there, taking a sharper swipe at the board’s broader selection philosophy.
“If that’s really how it’s going to be, then why not just let Bumrah go in Tests too? You keep telling us that in this transition phase, you’re not afraid to move on without superstar players—that you’ll bravely go ahead without them. So apply that logic here. Say you don’t want Bumrah either,” Ramesh said. “Except, obviously, you can’t do that—because there’s no other Bumrah.”

